Ranked by readers
The 25 best comics of the 2000s
Widescreen superheroes, Y: The Last Man and the rise of the trade paperback.
The top 25 of 387 comics of the 2000s on the board. We set the starting order. Reader votes move it. Vote on the full board.
1. All-Star Superman: Vol. 1
Morrison and Quitely's timeless love letter to Silver Age Superman; every issue is a complete fable and the best Superman comic ever made.
2. Invincible: Family Matters
Kirkman introduces Mark Grayson, a teenager whose father is the world's greatest superhero; warm, classic, and deceptively gentle before the bloodbath.
3. Y: The Last Man: Unmanned
Every mammal with a Y chromosome drops dead except Yorick and his monkey. Vaughan turns the premise into the decade’s sharpest road-trip thriller.
4. The Walking Dead: Days Gone Bye
Before the show, the comic: a cop wakes into the apocalypse and Kirkman makes the case that the living are the real horror.
5. Captain America: Winter Soldier Vol. 1
Brubaker resurrects Bucky Barnes as a Soviet assassin in arguably the best thing Marvel published in the 2000s. Epting's art is cold perfection.
6. Scott Pilgrim’s Precious Little Life
Video-game logic, Toronto slacker romance and seven evil exes. O’Malley invents a visual grammar the whole 2000s tried to copy.
#36 on the boardBuyAmazon7. DC: The New Frontier
Cooke recasts the Silver Age as Cold War optimism with teeth. The single most gorgeous love letter the DC heroes have ever received.
8. The Boys: The Name of the Game
Ennis's brutal satire of corporate superheroics imagines a world where supers are PR disasters; uncompromising, funny, and mean in the best way.
9. Locke & Key: Welcome to Lovecraft
A family of keys, a house that remembers, and Gabriel Rodriguez drawing grief as architecture. Modern horror comics’ high-water mark.
10. Scalped: Indian Country
An undercover Fed returns to the rez in a noir as bleak and sun-bleached as anything Vertigo published. Guéra’s art is all grit and bone.
11. Criminal: Coward
The crime comic Brubaker and Phillips were born to make: a heist, a pickpocket who can’t stop running, and prose-tight plotting.
12. Astro City: Life in the Big City
Busiek's love letter to superhero comics told entirely from the perspective of ordinary people; moving, humane, and brilliantly constructed.
13. Planetary: All Over the World
Ellis and Cassaday's archaeologists of the impossible uncover superhero mythology buried under the 20th century; formally jaw-dropping.
14. Batman: Hush Vol. 1
Loeb and Lee's glossy whodunit assembles Batman's entire rogues gallery behind a mysterious new villain. Lee's art remains breathtaking.
15. Ultimate Spider-Man: Power and Responsibility
Bendis and Bagley retell Spider-Man's origin for the modern era in this slow-burn, dialogue-rich reinvention that launched the Ultimate universe.
16. Fables: Legends in Exile
Fairy-tale characters in exile in modern New York, opening on a locked-room murder. Willingham’s long-running Vertigo cornerstone starts here.
17. Superman: Red Son
Superman’s rocket lands on a Soviet collective farm. Millar’s Cold War what-if turns the Man of Steel into a benevolent dictator and asks who the hero really is.
19. Batman and Robin: Batman Reborn
Dick Grayson becomes Batman and Damian becomes Robin; Morrison and Quitely invert the classic dynamic in a bright, almost joyful arc.
#69 on the boardBuyAmazon20. Invincible: Eight is Enough
Mark's world expands with the Teen Team; Ottley joins and the series finds its visual voice before Kirkman pulls the rug out entirely.
21. Captain America: Winter Soldier Vol. 2
The truth about the Winter Soldier is revealed; Brubaker's Cold War thriller reaches its heartbreaking emotional core.
22. Green Lantern: Sinestro Corps War Vol. 1
The Yellow Lanterns declare war; Johns's Green Lantern reaches its bombastic action peak with the introduction of the emotional spectrum.
#77 on the boardBuyAmazon23. Gotham Central: In the Line of Duty
Brubaker and Rucka's police procedural views Gotham from street level; what does it feel like to be a cop in a city with Batman? Lark's art is perfect.
#78 on the boardBuyAmazon24. Essex County
Generations of a rural Ontario farming community, an orphaned boy, an old hockey player and a nurse. Lemire’s breakthrough.
25. Iron Man: Extremis
A super-soldier virus is loose and Tony rebuilds himself to stop it. Ellis and Granov modernised Iron Man, and the films took notes.
Buy links are affiliate links: purchases support The Long Box at no extra cost. Affiliate disclosure
























