Ranked by readers
The 25 best X-Men comics
Feared and hated by a world they’ve sworn to protect. Claremont to Krakoa, best first.
The top 25 of 50 X-Men comics on the board. We set the starting order. Reader votes move it. Vote on the full board.
1. X-Men: The Dark Phoenix Saga
Jean Grey is corrupted by cosmic power and the X-Men have to decide whether she deserves to live. Claremont and Byrne’s operatic peak.
2. House of X
Hickman completely redefines mutantkind: Krakoa as nation, resurrection protocols, and a new geopolitical order. The most important X-Men story in decades.
#23 on the boardBuyAmazon3. Ms. Marvel: No Normal
G. Willow Wilson introduces Kamala Khan, a Pakistani-American teenager from Jersey City who becomes Marvel's most beloved new hero in decades.
4. X-Men: Days of Future Past
In a future of mutant internment camps, Kitty Pryde’s mind is sent back to stop the assassination that starts it all. Two issues that shaped forty years of X-Men.
5. Powers of X
The secret history and far future of mutants; Hickman's companion to HoX recontextualizes a hundred years of X-Men history.
6. Astonishing X-Men: Gifted
Whedon and Cassaday strip the X-Men back to their heroic essence; a cure for mutation becomes the catalyst for an instantly classic run.
7. New X-Men: E Is for Extinction
Morrison's revolutionary reinvention of the X-Men opens with Cassandra Nova annihilating Genosha and a sleeker, more cinematic aesthetic replacing decades of soap opera.
8. Uncanny X-Force: The Apocalypse Solution
Remender sends X-Force to kill the reincarnated Apocalypse — a child — in an arc that poses the darkest possible ethical question.
#185 on the boardBuyAmazon9. Uncanny X-Force: The Dark Angel Saga Book 1
The Age of Apocalypse is revisited; Warren Worthington's Archangel nature resurfaces and Remender begins his magnum opus.
#257 on the boardBuyAmazon10. Uncanny X-Force: The Dark Angel Saga Book 2
Remender's masterwork concludes with sacrifice, tragedy, and the best X-Men story in a decade. Opeña's art is staggering.
#313 on the boardBuyAmazon11. Astonishing X-Men: Dangerous
The Danger Room becomes sentient; Whedon's second arc is slightly looser but still gorgeous and emotionally sharp.
12. New X-Men: Imperial
The X-Men head to space; Morrison expands his mutant mythology with the Shi'ar Empire and the murder of Charles Xavier's dark secret.
#349 on the boardBuyAmazon13. Astonishing X-Men: Torn
Cassandra Nova returns to break the X-Men from within; Whedon's run at its most emotionally devastating.
14. New X-Men: New Worlds
The school era deepens as Xorn becomes a teacher and the complicated relationship between Scott Summers and Emma Frost comes to a head.
15. Astonishing X-Men: Unstoppable
The X-Men travel to the Breakworld to stop a bullet aimed at Earth; Whedon's bittersweet, sacrificial finale.
16. New X-Men: Here Comes Tomorrow
Morrison's devastating finale set 150 years in the future; a bleak epilogue that argues for hope over safety.
17. X-Men Red: The Great Designs
Ewing turns Arakko into a planet of rival philosophies and lets Storm rule. The smartest, most political book of the Krakoan era.
#447 on the boardBuyAmazon18. New X-Men: Planet X
Magneto's shocking and drug-fueled return burns Morrison's run to the ground; the most divisive arc in the run and still unforgettable.
19. S.W.O.R.D.: Power, Peace, and the X-Men
Ewing's mutant space program is the most fun X-book in the Krakoa era; Storm, Cable, and Brand in a brilliantly constructed space opera.
#487 on the boardBuyAmazon20. Excalibur: The Sword is Drawn
Tini Howard's Betsy Braddock as Captain Britain explores the mystical Otherworld; colorful, mythologically rich, and romantically charged.
#512 on the boardBuyAmazon21. X-Men Red: Waging Peace
Ewing's Storm-led mutant geopolitics on Mars is bracingly fresh; superhero meets sci-fi colony drama with a sharp moral compass.
#611 on the boardBuyAmazon22. X-Men: God Loves, Man Kills
A televangelist preaches a crusade against mutants and kidnaps Xavier to make it real. The X-Men’s most direct story about bigotry.
23. X-Men: From the Ashes
Cyclops marries Madelyne Pryor, who looks exactly like Jean Grey, and Storm gets a mohawk. Claremont and Paul Smith at their best.
#721 on the boardBuyAmazon24. X-Men: Mutant Massacre
The Marauders slaughter the Morlocks in the tunnels under New York. The crossover that made the X-books darker and bloodier.
25. X-Men: Mutant Genesis
Magneto, his Acolytes and an asteroid fortress, in the best-selling comic book of all time. Jim Lee’s X-Men at full gloss.
Buy links are affiliate links: purchases support The Long Box at no extra cost. Affiliate disclosure
























