Ranked by readers
The 12 best Captain America comics
A soldier out of time, and Marvel’s conscience.
We set the starting order. Reader votes move it. Vote on the full board.
1. Captain America: Winter Soldier Vol. 1
Brubaker resurrects Bucky Barnes as a Soviet assassin in arguably the best thing Marvel published in the 2000s. Epting's art is cold perfection.
2. Captain America: Winter Soldier Vol. 2
The truth about the Winter Soldier is revealed; Brubaker's Cold War thriller reaches its heartbreaking emotional core.
3. Captain America: White
Cap and Bucky in occupied France, with Steve looking back on the boy he lost. Loeb and Sale’s long-delayed colour-series finale.
#163 on the boardBuyAmazon4. Captain America: Madbomb
Kirby returns to the hero he created in 1941: a bomb that drives people mad, set for America’s bicentennial.
5. Captain America: War & Remembrance
Steve Rogers is asked to run for president and has to decide what he stands for. A short, classic run by Stern and Byrne.
6. Captain America: Operation Rebirth
Cap teams up with the Red Skull to recover a Cosmic Cube from Hitler’s ghost. Waid and Garney’s return to form.
7. Captain America: Red Menace
Brubaker expands the Red Skull's Cold War mythology with noir precision; a necessary companion to the Winter Soldier arc.
8. The Death of Captain America
Steve Rogers is assassinated on the courthouse steps; Brubaker turns the event into a meditation on legacy, identity, and grief.
9. Captain America: Reborn
Steve Rogers returns from being unstuck in time; not Brubaker's tightest work but a satisfying conclusion to his defining arc.
10. Captain America: Castaway in Dimension Z
Cap is trapped for twelve years in Arnim Zola’s nightmare dimension, raising a boy he rescued. Remender and Romita Jr. go pulp.
11. Captain America: Winter in America
Coates writes Steve Rogers as a man unsure his country still wants him. A thoughtful, sober take, drawn with weight by Leinil Yu.
12. Captain America: Man Out of Time
Steve Rogers wakes from the ice into a world he doesn’t recognise. Waid retells the moment Captain America lost his era.
#1076 on the boardBuyAmazon
Buy links are affiliate links: purchases support The Long Box at no extra cost. Affiliate disclosure











