Ranked by readers
The 25 best Ed Brubaker comics
Criminal, Captain America, Reckless and decades of noir.
The top 25 of 40 Ed Brubaker comics on the board. We set the starting order. Reader votes move it. Vote on the full board.
1. Captain America: Winter Soldier Vol. 1
Brubaker resurrects Bucky Barnes as a Soviet assassin in arguably the best thing Marvel published in the 2000s. Epting's art is cold perfection.
2. Criminal: Coward
The crime comic Brubaker and Phillips were born to make: a heist, a pickpocket who can’t stop running, and prose-tight plotting.
3. Captain America: Winter Soldier Vol. 2
The truth about the Winter Soldier is revealed; Brubaker's Cold War thriller reaches its heartbreaking emotional core.
4. Gotham Central: In the Line of Duty
Brubaker and Rucka's police procedural views Gotham from street level; what does it feel like to be a cop in a city with Batman? Lark's art is perfect.
#78 on the boardBuyAmazon5. Criminal: Lawless
Tracy Lawless comes home to bury his brother and burn down whoever did it. Brubaker and Phillips’ revenge engine at full throttle.
6. The Fade Out: Act One
Blacklist-era Hollywood, a dead starlet and a screenwriter who can’t remember the night. Phillips and Breitweiser make 1948 glow and rot.
7. Kill or Be Killed: Vol. 1
A vigilante who kills to keep a demon at bay — or to keep his own guilt at bay. Brubaker’s most slippery, modern noir.
8. Sleeper: Out in the Cold
A deep-cover agent stranded with no way back in, in a superhuman underworld. Brubaker and Phillips’ first great collaboration.
#148 on the boardBuyAmazon9. Incognito
A retired supervillain in witness protection gets bored and slips. Pulp-noir with capes, drawn in Phillips’ glorious shadow.
10. Velvet: Before the Living End
The secretary of a spy agency turns out to be its best agent, framed for murder and running. Epting draws 70s espionage at its slickest.
11. Immortal Iron Fist: The Last Iron Fist Story
Brubaker and Fraction reinvent Danny Rand with kung fu mythology, cold war conspiracy, and Aja's kinetic page design. Career-best work.
12. Fatale: Death Chases Me
Lovecraft meets the femme fatale across decades. Brubaker and Phillips fold cosmic horror into noir without spilling either.
13. The Fade Out: Act Three
Hollywood noir’s ending is as cruel as the town. Brubaker and Phillips’ best book.
14. Fatale: The Devil’s Business
1970s Los Angeles, a fading actor and a cult that won’t die. Brubaker and Phillips keep folding Lovecraft into the rot of Hollywood.
15. The Fade Out: Act Two
The studio covers up a starlet’s death and the screenwriter who found her keeps digging.
16. Immortal Iron Fist: The Seven Capital Cities of Heaven
The tournament of the seven Iron Fists; Marvel's most inventive martial arts epic and one of the best-designed superhero comics ever made.
#333 on the boardBuyAmazon17. Sleeper: All False Moves
Holden Carver goes deeper into the criminal organisation he has infiltrated and starts forgetting whose side he’s on.
#345 on the boardBuyAmazon18. Catwoman: The Dark End of the Street
Brubaker and Cooke reinvent Selina as a protector of the East End. The goggles, the noir, the whole modern Catwoman starts here.
19. Criminal: Bad Night
An insomniac cartoonist gets tangled with a femme fatale and a robbery he shouldn’t have seen. Brubaker and Phillips at their most twisted.
20. Gotham Central: Unresolved Targets
More cop-shop Gotham from Brubaker, Rucka and Lark. The Mad Hatter and Penguin seen entirely from the detectives’ exhausted side of the glass.
#381 on the boardBuyAmazon21. Criminal: Last of the Innocent
A man murders his way back to his small-town past, drawn in poisoned Archie-comic flashbacks. The cleverest thing the duo ever made.
22. Where the Body Was
One summer in 1984, on one street of teenagers, cops, a teen detective and a junkie, leading to one body.
23. Catwoman: Relentless
Brubaker and Cameron Stewart push Selina against a sadistic new threat. Crime comics with claws; one of the best Catwoman arcs ever.
24. Night Fever
A publisher at a book fair in Europe can’t sleep and follows a stranger into the nightlife, and into a different self.
25. Reckless: Friend of the Devil
Ethan Reckless takes a missing-person job into 1980s cult country. The second of Brubaker and Phillips’ lean paperback-noir OGNs.
Buy links are affiliate links: purchases support The Long Box at no extra cost. Affiliate disclosure

























