Ranked by readers
The 25 best crime and noir comics
Heists, crooked cops and bad decisions.
The top 25 of 197 crime and noir comics on the board. We set the starting order. Reader votes move it. Vote on the full board.
1. Batman: Year One
Jim Gordon arrives in a rotten Gotham the same year Bruce Wayne first puts on the cowl. Miller and Mazzucchelli’s lean noir is the origin every later Batman borrows from.
#10 on the boardBuyAmazon2. Daredevil: Born Again
The Kingpin learns Matt Murdock’s secret and takes everything from him. Miller and Mazzucchelli’s story of a man rebuilt from nothing.
3. Batman: The Long Halloween
A killer strikes Gotham’s mob on every holiday for a year. Loeb and Sale’s whodunit charts the fall of Harvey Dent and the end of the gangster era.
#26 on the boardBuyAmazon4. Preacher: Gone to Texas
A Texas preacher fused with the child of an angel and a demon sets out to find God and make Him answer. Ennis and Dillon’s blasphemous road movie.
5. Sin City: The Hard Goodbye
Marv, a brute with a condition, hunts the killer of the one woman who was kind to him. Miller’s black-and-white noir is all silhouette and rain.
6. Gotham Central: In the Line of Duty
Brubaker and Rucka's police procedural views Gotham from street level; what does it feel like to be a cop in a city with Batman? Lark's art is perfect.
#78 on the boardBuyAmazon7. Southern Bastards: Here Was a Man
Aaron's brutal Southern noir; an old man returns to his corrupt Alabama hometown and confronts the coach who runs everything. Devastating opening.
8. Lazarus: Family
Rucka's near-future dystopia where corporate families control the world and wage war through genetically enhanced soldiers called Lazari.
9. Human Target
Tom King's noir murder mystery; Christopher Chance has twelve days to live and every member of the JLA is a suspect. Smallwood's art is flawless.
10. Wolverine: Claremont & Miller
Wolverine goes to Japan for the woman he loves and finds a crime family and his own code. The mini that made Logan a samurai.
11. Batman: Dark Victory
A new holiday killer, the costumed freaks pushing out the mob, and a circus boy named Dick Grayson losing his parents. The Long Halloween’s sequel, just as good.
12. Daredevil: Frank Miller & Klaus Janson Vol. 1
Miller arrives as artist, then writer: Bullseye, the Kingpin and the first appearance of Elektra.
#138 on the boardBuyAmazon13. Parker: The Hunter
Richard Stark’s cold-blooded thief walks back into New York to collect what he’s owed. Cooke adapts it in two-colour, early-60s cool.
14. The Black Monday Murders: All Hail, God Mammon
The world’s great banking families are secretly cults of money, and a detective investigates a ritual murder on Wall Street.
15. The Spirit: Book One
Darwyn Cooke revives Eisner’s masked detective with wit, wonderful lettering and modern Central City.
16. Velvet: Before the Living End
The secretary of a spy agency turns out to be its best agent, framed for murder and running. Epting draws 70s espionage at its slickest.
17. Batman: The Long Halloween: The Last Halloween
Loeb returns to the holiday-killer formula for one last Gotham mystery, with a different guest artist drawing each issue.
18. Fell: Feral City
A detective exiled across the bridge to a rotting city solves one case per issue. Ellis’s experiment in compressed comics.
19. Catwoman: Selina’s Big Score
Selina Kyle plans one perfect train heist with a crew of crooks. Darwyn Cooke’s Parker-flavoured caper.
20. Alias: Vol. 1
Bendis introduces Jessica Jones — superhero-turned-PI — in Marvel's first MAX series; raw, funny, and unlike anything else at the time.
21. The Fade Out: Act Three
Hollywood noir’s ending is as cruel as the town. Brubaker and Phillips’ best book.
22. Queen & Country: Operation: Broken Ground
Tara Chace, a British intelligence operative, carries out an assassination in Kosovo and the fallout follows her home.
23. Powers: Who Killed Retro Girl?
Bendis's police procedural set in a world of superheroes; Walker and Pilgrim investigate the murder of the world's greatest hero.
24. Southern Bastards: Gridiron
Aaron flips perspective to Coach Boss; the villain's story is as compelling as the hero's in this morally complex Southern crime epic.
25. Ice Haven
A boy’s disappearance ripples through a small Midwestern town, told as a chorus of comic strips in different styles. Clowes at his most formally daring.
Buy links are affiliate links: purchases support The Long Box at no extra cost. Affiliate disclosure


























