Ranked by readers
The 25 best Dark Horse comics
Hellboy, Sin City and four decades of creator-owned books.
The top 25 of 69 Dark Horse comics on the board. We set the starting order. Reader votes move it. Vote on the full board.
1. Hellboy: Seed of Destruction
The demon raised by the Allies investigates the death of his adoptive father and meets the man who summoned him. Mignola’s shadows arrive fully formed.
2. Black Hammer: Secret Origins
Lemire's heroes are stranded in a small town with no memory of how they arrived; a meditation on superhero mythology, retirement, and regret.
3. Sin City: The Hard Goodbye
Marv, a brute with a condition, hunts the killer of the one woman who was kind to him. Miller’s black-and-white noir is all silhouette and rain.
4. Usagi Yojimbo: Grasscutter
The legendary sword Kusanagi resurfaces and every faction wants it. Sakai’s most ambitious epic, rich with Japanese myth.
5. Hellboy: The Chained Coffin and Others
Short stories drawn from folklore, including the night Hellboy learns who his mother was. Mignola at his most poetic.
6. Hellboy: Wake the Devil
Rasputin’s followers revive a vampire in a Romanian castle and Hellboy learns more about his destiny than he wants.
7. B.P.R.D.: Plague of Frogs
The Hellboy spinoff comes into its own as a sprawling apocalypse procedural. Guy Davis draws the most unsettling monsters in comics.
8. Fear Agent: Re-Ignition
A boozy, last-of-his-kind alien exterminator barrels through pulp space opera. Remender and Tony Moore wear their EC Comics love loud.
9. Alice in Sunderland
A performance in a Sunderland theatre becomes a dizzying history of the city and its ties to Lewis Carroll.
10. The Goon: Nothin’ But Misery
Zombie gangsters, slapstick and sudden heartbreak, all drawn in Powell’s gorgeous painted grime. Unlike anything else on the shelf.
11. Finder: Library Vol. 1
Jaeger, a half-breed tracker, drifts through a domed far-future city of clans and castes. McNeil’s richly imagined anthropological sci-fi.
#259 on the boardBuyAmazon12. The Tale of One Bad Rat
A teenage runaway escaping abuse follows Beatrix Potter’s trail to the Lake District. Talbot’s tender, devastating story of recovery.
#267 on the boardBuyAmazon13. Concrete: Depths
A speechwriter’s brain is put into a huge stone body by aliens, and he tries to live a quiet, curious life. Chadwick’s thoughtful, humane sci-fi.
14. Grendel: Devil by the Deed
Hunter Rose, novelist by day and crime lord by night, told as an illustrated biography. The first Grendel, and Wagner’s most elegant.
15. Nexus: Omnibus Vol. 1
A man who dreams the crimes of mass murderers is compelled to execute them. Baron and Rude’s cosmic hero with a conscience.
#321 on the boardBuyAmazon16. Sin City: A Dame to Kill For
Dwight McCarthy falls for the woman who ruined him, again. Miller’s purest femme-fatale story.
17. Sin City: That Yellow Bastard
An honest cop with a bad heart saves a girl from a senator’s son and pays for it for years. Sin City’s most romantic book, with one colour.
18. Helen of Wyndhorn
The daughter of a dead pulp writer goes to her grandfather’s mansion and finds his stories were true. Evely’s art is spectacular.
19. Hellboy: The Right Hand of Doom
Hellboy confronts what his stone hand is for, between stories of witches and wolves.
20. Hellboy: Darkness Calls
Hellboy hunted by witches and Baba Yaga across a folkloric Russia. Duncan Fegredo’s line makes Mignola’s myth-world sing.
21. Mazebook
A grieving building inspector gets a phone call from his dead daughter and follows a maze she drew into another world.
22. Hellboy: The Crooked Man and Others
Hellboy in 1950s Appalachia, hunting a devil who trades in souls. Corben’s grotesque art is the perfect fit.
23. B.P.R.D.: The Dead
The Bureau moves to a new base in Colorado, and Abe Sapien uncovers his past life. Davis’s art becomes the face of the series.
24. Bandette: Presto!
A teenage cat burglar in Paris steals for fun and helps the police when she feels like it. Pure, bubbly joy.
25. Black Hammer: Age of Doom Part 1
Lemire and Ormston deepen their melancholy riff on the Justice League stranded on a farm. The mystery of the town finally cracks.
#622 on the boardBuyAmazon
Buy links are affiliate links: purchases support The Long Box at no extra cost. Affiliate disclosure


























