Ranked by readers

The 25 best Dark Horse comics

Hellboy, Sin City and four decades of creator-owned books.

The top 25 of 69 Dark Horse comics on the board. We set the starting order. Reader votes move it. Vote on the full board.

  1. 1. Hellboy: Seed of Destruction

    Mike Mignola · 1994 · Independent

    The demon raised by the Allies investigates the death of his adoptive father and meets the man who summoned him. Mignola’s shadows arrive fully formed.

    #15 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  2. 2. Black Hammer: Secret Origins

    Jeff Lemire & Dean Ormston · 2017 · Independent

    Lemire's heroes are stranded in a small town with no memory of how they arrived; a meditation on superhero mythology, retirement, and regret.

    #42 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  3. 3. Sin City: The Hard Goodbye

    Frank Miller · 1991 · Independent

    Marv, a brute with a condition, hunts the killer of the one woman who was kind to him. Miller’s black-and-white noir is all silhouette and rain.

    #55 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  4. 4. Usagi Yojimbo: Grasscutter

    Stan Sakai · 1997 · Independent

    The legendary sword Kusanagi resurfaces and every faction wants it. Sakai’s most ambitious epic, rich with Japanese myth.

    #58 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  5. 5. Hellboy: The Chained Coffin and Others

    Mike Mignola · 1994 · Independent

    Short stories drawn from folklore, including the night Hellboy learns who his mother was. Mignola at his most poetic.

    #72 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  6. 6. Hellboy: Wake the Devil

    Mike Mignola · 1996 · Independent

    Rasputin’s followers revive a vampire in a Romanian castle and Hellboy learns more about his destiny than he wants.

    #149 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  7. 7. B.P.R.D.: Plague of Frogs

    Mike Mignola & Guy Davis · 2005 · Independent

    The Hellboy spinoff comes into its own as a sprawling apocalypse procedural. Guy Davis draws the most unsettling monsters in comics.

    #150 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  8. 8. Fear Agent: Re-Ignition

    Rick Remender & Tony Moore · 2007 · Independent

    A boozy, last-of-his-kind alien exterminator barrels through pulp space opera. Remender and Tony Moore wear their EC Comics love loud.

    #180 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  9. 9. Alice in Sunderland

    Bryan Talbot · 2007 · Other

    A performance in a Sunderland theatre becomes a dizzying history of the city and its ties to Lewis Carroll.

    #182 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  10. 10. The Goon: Nothin’ But Misery

    Eric Powell · 2003 · Independent

    Zombie gangsters, slapstick and sudden heartbreak, all drawn in Powell’s gorgeous painted grime. Unlike anything else on the shelf.

    #208 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  11. 11. Finder: Library Vol. 1

    Carla Speed McNeil · 1996 · Independent

    Jaeger, a half-breed tracker, drifts through a domed far-future city of clans and castes. McNeil’s richly imagined anthropological sci-fi.

    #259 on the boardBuyAmazon
  12. 12. The Tale of One Bad Rat

    Bryan Talbot · 1994 · Independent

    A teenage runaway escaping abuse follows Beatrix Potter’s trail to the Lake District. Talbot’s tender, devastating story of recovery.

    #267 on the boardBuyAmazon
  13. 13. Concrete: Depths

    Paul Chadwick · 1986 · Independent

    A speechwriter’s brain is put into a huge stone body by aliens, and he tries to live a quiet, curious life. Chadwick’s thoughtful, humane sci-fi.

    #306 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  14. 14. Grendel: Devil by the Deed

    Matt Wagner · 1985 · Independent

    Hunter Rose, novelist by day and crime lord by night, told as an illustrated biography. The first Grendel, and Wagner’s most elegant.

    #308 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  15. 15. Nexus: Omnibus Vol. 1

    Mike Baron & Steve Rude · 1981 · Independent

    A man who dreams the crimes of mass murderers is compelled to execute them. Baron and Rude’s cosmic hero with a conscience.

    #321 on the boardBuyAmazon
  16. 16. Sin City: A Dame to Kill For

    Frank Miller · 1993 · Independent

    Dwight McCarthy falls for the woman who ruined him, again. Miller’s purest femme-fatale story.

    #362 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  17. 17. Sin City: That Yellow Bastard

    Frank Miller · 1996 · Independent

    An honest cop with a bad heart saves a girl from a senator’s son and pays for it for years. Sin City’s most romantic book, with one colour.

    #398 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  18. 18. Helen of Wyndhorn

    Tom King & Bilquis Evely · 2024 · Independent

    The daughter of a dead pulp writer goes to her grandfather’s mansion and finds his stories were true. Evely’s art is spectacular.

    #403 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  19. 19. Hellboy: The Right Hand of Doom

    Mike Mignola · 2000 · Independent

    Hellboy confronts what his stone hand is for, between stories of witches and wolves.

    #441 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  20. 20. Hellboy: Darkness Calls

    Mike Mignola & Duncan Fegredo · 2008 · Independent

    Hellboy hunted by witches and Baba Yaga across a folkloric Russia. Duncan Fegredo’s line makes Mignola’s myth-world sing.

    #452 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  21. 21. Mazebook

    Jeff Lemire · 2021 · Independent

    A grieving building inspector gets a phone call from his dead daughter and follows a maze she drew into another world.

    #494 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  22. 22. Hellboy: The Crooked Man and Others

    Mike Mignola & Richard Corben · 2008 · Independent

    Hellboy in 1950s Appalachia, hunting a devil who trades in souls. Corben’s grotesque art is the perfect fit.

    #517 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  23. 23. B.P.R.D.: The Dead

    Mike Mignola & Guy Davis · 2004 · Independent

    The Bureau moves to a new base in Colorado, and Abe Sapien uncovers his past life. Davis’s art becomes the face of the series.

    #597 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  24. 24. Bandette: Presto!

    Paul Tobin & Colleen Coover · 2012 · Independent

    A teenage cat burglar in Paris steals for fun and helps the police when she feels like it. Pure, bubbly joy.

    #603 on the boardBuyBookshopAmazon
  25. 25. Black Hammer: Age of Doom Part 1

    Jeff Lemire & Dean Ormston · 2018 · Independent

    Lemire and Ormston deepen their melancholy riff on the Justice League stranded on a farm. The mystery of the town finally cracks.

    #622 on the boardBuyAmazon

Buy links are affiliate links: purchases support The Long Box at no extra cost. Affiliate disclosure