Ranked by readers
The 25 best indie comics
Everything outside Marvel and DC.
The top 25 of 602 indie comics on the board. We set the starting order. Reader votes move it. Vote on the full board.
1. Hellboy: Seed of Destruction
The demon raised by the Allies investigates the death of his adoptive father and meets the man who summoned him. Mignola’s shadows arrive fully formed.
2. Invincible: Family Matters
Kirkman introduces Mark Grayson, a teenager whose father is the world's greatest superhero; warm, classic, and deceptively gentle before the bloodbath.
3. Something Is Killing the Children: Vol. 1
Tynion's monster-hunting horror with the enigmatic Erica Slaughter; atmospheric, emotionally complex, and genuinely frightening.
4. Transformers: Robots in Disguise
The Autobots and Decepticons crash-land on Earth and wake up in the middle of a war that two humans get swept into. Johnson’s thunderous relaunch.
#25 on the boardBuyAmazon5. The Walking Dead: Days Gone Bye
Before the show, the comic: a cop wakes into the apocalypse and Kirkman makes the case that the living are the real horror.
6. Saga: Vol. 1
Vaughan and Staples's sci-fi epic about two soldiers from warring species raising a baby; the best new comic of the 2010s begins here.
#28 on the boardBuyAmazon7. Out from Boneville
Three cartoon cousins run away from home and get lost in a valley of dragons and rat creatures. Pogo meets The Lord of the Rings.
8. Scott Pilgrim’s Precious Little Life
Video-game logic, Toronto slacker romance and seven evil exes. O’Malley invents a visual grammar the whole 2000s tried to copy.
#36 on the boardBuyAmazon9. Department of Truth: Vol. 1
Tynion's conspiracy horror: belief literally shapes reality, and there are government agents whose job is to manage what America believes.
10. The Boys: The Name of the Game
Ennis's brutal satire of corporate superheroics imagines a world where supers are PR disasters; uncompromising, funny, and mean in the best way.
11. Monstress: Awakening
Sana Takeda’s art deco nightmare wrapped around Liu’s tale of war, trauma and a girl bonded to something hungry. Sumptuous and brutal.
12. Black Hammer: Secret Origins
Lemire's heroes are stranded in a small town with no memory of how they arrived; a meditation on superhero mythology, retirement, and regret.
13. Locke & Key: Welcome to Lovecraft
A family of keys, a house that remembers, and Gabriel Rodriguez drawing grief as architecture. Modern horror comics’ high-water mark.
14. Criminal: Coward
The crime comic Brubaker and Phillips were born to make: a heist, a pickpocket who can’t stop running, and prose-tight plotting.
15. Paper Girls: Vol. 1
Vaughan's time-travel saga starring four paper delivery girls who stumble into a war between factions from different futures on Halloween 1988.
16. Astro City: Life in the Big City
Busiek's love letter to superhero comics told entirely from the perspective of ordinary people; moving, humane, and brilliantly constructed.
17. Ghost World
Enid and Rebecca drift through the summer after high school mocking everything and growing apart. Clowes nails the end of a friendship.
18. Sin City: The Hard Goodbye
Marv, a brute with a condition, hunts the killer of the one woman who was kind to him. Miller’s black-and-white noir is all silhouette and rain.
19. Usagi Yojimbo: Grasscutter
The legendary sword Kusanagi resurfaces and every faction wants it. Sakai’s most ambitious epic, rich with Japanese myth.
20. Love and Rockets: Locas
Maggie and Hopey, punk and love in a Southern California barrio, followed for decades. Jaime Hernandez’s half of the great American comic.
21. Black Hole
In 1970s Seattle a sexually transmitted plague mutates teenagers. Burns’s inky body horror is about adolescence at its most frightening.
22. Saga: Vol. 2
The family flees across a war-torn galaxy; the world expands, the art dazzles, and the book becomes genuinely addictive.
23. Invincible: Eight is Enough
Mark's world expands with the Teen Team; Ottley joins and the series finds its visual voice before Kirkman pulls the rug out entirely.
24. Hellboy: The Chained Coffin and Others
Short stories drawn from folklore, including the night Hellboy learns who his mother was. Mignola at his most poetic.
25. East of West: The Promise
Hickman's alternate American history: Death seeks revenge, the apocalypse approaches, and four horsemen ride. Dense, rewarding, stunning.
Buy links are affiliate links: purchases support The Long Box at no extra cost. Affiliate disclosure
























