Ranked by readers
The 25 best DC comics
Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman and the rest of DC, best first.
The top 25 of 457 DC comics on the board. We set the starting order. Reader votes move it. Vote on the full board.
1. Watchmen
Retired masked vigilantes, a murdered Comedian and a doomsday clock at five to midnight. The book that rewired what superhero comics could be.
2. Kingdom Come
A retired Superman returns to rein in a reckless new generation, and the apocalypse comes anyway. Ross paints DC’s future with biblical weight.
3. Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
A fifty-five-year-old Bruce Wayne comes out of retirement into a Gotham of TV pundits and mutant gangs. The book that made Batman grim and made comics the news.
4. Superman: The Warworld Saga
Phillip Kennedy Johnson sends Superman to Warworld to free its enslaved people, and the gladiator epic that follows becomes a story about what it costs to stay kind when the whole planet is built to break you.
5. Mister Miracle
Tom King and Mitch Gerads use the New Gods to construct a meditation on PTSD, depression, and the will to keep living. A modern masterpiece.
6. Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow
A grizzled space western with Kara as the gunslinger a dying girl recruits for revenge. Bilquis Evely draws the whole galaxy by hand.
7. Batman: Year One
Jim Gordon arrives in a rotten Gotham the same year Bruce Wayne first puts on the cowl. Miller and Mazzucchelli’s lean noir is the origin every later Batman borrows from.
#10 on the boardBuyAmazon8. All-Star Superman: Vol. 1
Morrison and Quitely's timeless love letter to Silver Age Superman; every issue is a complete fable and the best Superman comic ever made.
9. Wonder Woman: Outlaw
After an Amazon’s crime, the US government declares all Amazons illegal, and Diana becomes a fugitive.
10. Absolute Batman: The Zoo
A Batman without the Wayne fortune: a working-class engineer with a huge build and a homemade arsenal, in a brutal new Gotham.
11. Y: The Last Man: Unmanned
Every mammal with a Y chromosome drops dead except Yorick and his monkey. Vaughan turns the premise into the decade’s sharpest road-trip thriller.
12. JLA: New World Order
Morrison puts the big seven back together and writes them as a pantheon. The first arc of the run that made the Justice League matter again.
13. V for Vendetta
A masked anarchist takes on a fascist Britain one explosion at a time. Moore and Lloyd’s furious, ambiguous fable about freedom and terror.
14. Batman: The Long Halloween
A killer strikes Gotham’s mob on every holiday for a year. Loeb and Sale’s whodunit charts the fall of Harvey Dent and the end of the gangster era.
#26 on the boardBuyAmazon15. Preacher: Gone to Texas
A Texas preacher fused with the child of an angel and a demon sets out to find God and make Him answer. Ennis and Dillon’s blasphemous road movie.
16. The Nice House on the Lake: Vol. 1
Friends invited to a lake house survive the end of the world — then discover why they were chosen. Bueno makes dread look serene.
17. Absolute Wonder Woman: The Last Amazon
Raised in Hell by the witch Circe, this Diana comes to Earth as an outsider armed with a witch’s magic.
18. Batman: The Court of Owls
Snyder and Capullo introduce a secret Gotham conspiracy centuries old; the best sustained new Batman mythology in a generation.
19. DC: The New Frontier
Cooke recasts the Silver Age as Cold War optimism with teeth. The single most gorgeous love letter the DC heroes have ever received.
20. Scalped: Indian Country
An undercover Fed returns to the rez in a noir as bleak and sun-bleached as anything Vertigo published. Guéra’s art is all grit and bone.
21. Planetary: All Over the World
Ellis and Cassaday's archaeologists of the impossible uncover superhero mythology buried under the 20th century; formally jaw-dropping.
22. Batman: Hush Vol. 1
Loeb and Lee's glossy whodunit assembles Batman's entire rogues gallery behind a mysterious new villain. Lee's art remains breathtaking.
23. Saga of the Swamp Thing Book One
Swamp Thing learns he was never Alec Holland, just a plant that thought it was. The issue that rewired horror comics, and the run that followed.
#53 on the boardBuyAmazon24. Batman: The Killing Joke
One bad day, the Joker argues, is all it takes. Moore and Bolland’s short, cruel two-hander still sets the terms for every Joker story since.
25. Fables: Legends in Exile
Fairy-tale characters in exile in modern New York, opening on a locked-room murder. Willingham’s long-running Vertigo cornerstone starts here.
Buy links are affiliate links: purchases support The Long Box at no extra cost. Affiliate disclosure

























