Ranked by readers
The 25 best Superman comics
The hardest hero to write well, and the best when someone pulls it off.
The top 25 of 39 Superman comics on the board. We set the starting order. Reader votes move it. Vote on the full board.
1. Kingdom Come
A retired Superman returns to rein in a reckless new generation, and the apocalypse comes anyway. Ross paints DC’s future with biblical weight.
2. Superman: The Warworld Saga
Phillip Kennedy Johnson sends Superman to Warworld to free its enslaved people, and the gladiator epic that follows becomes a story about what it costs to stay kind when the whole planet is built to break you.
3. All-Star Superman: Vol. 1
Morrison and Quitely's timeless love letter to Silver Age Superman; every issue is a complete fable and the best Superman comic ever made.
4. Superman: Red Son
Superman’s rocket lands on a Soviet collective farm. Millar’s Cold War what-if turns the Man of Steel into a benevolent dictator and asks who the hero really is.
5. Superman for All Seasons
Four seasons, four narrators and one young man from Smallville learning what he’s for. The warmest book Loeb and Sale made together.
6. Superman: Birthright
A young Clark Kent who can see souls, a Lex Luthor who never forgave Smallville, and a Superman who chooses to be kind. Waid’s origin for a new century.
7. Superman: Secret Identity
Busiek's masterpiece: a boy named Clark Kent discovers he genuinely has Superman's powers in the real world. Immonen's watercolor art is stunning.
8. Superman: Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow?
Moore’s farewell to the Silver Age Superman, framed as an imaginary story. Every old villain returns meaner, and it ends on a wink that still lands.
9. Superman: Reign of the Supermen
After Superman’s death, four new Supermen appear, and one of them is a killer.
10. Absolute Superman: Last Dust of Krypton
Kal-El reaches Earth with no Kents to raise him, a refugee from a Krypton ruled by class. A Superman of the working poor.
11. Superman: For Tomorrow
Superman confesses to a priest that he caused a million people to vanish, and goes looking for them. Azzarello and Jim Lee’s moody epic.
12. Superman: Up, Up and Away!
A year after losing his powers, Clark Kent is a star reporter, until Luthor’s schemes need Superman back.
#449 on the boardBuyAmazon13. Superman: Space Age
Superman’s career from the Kennedy assassination to the end of the world, told as one life. Russell and Allred’s pop-art elegy for American optimism.
14. Superman: Secret Origin
Superman’s origin from Smallville to the Daily Planet, with Gary Frank’s Christopher Reeve-tinged Clark. Clean, generous and easy to love.
15. Batman/Superman: World’s Finest: The Devil Nezha
Early in their partnership, Batman, Superman and Robin face a demon from Chinese myth. Waid and Mora’s joyful throwback.
#470 on the boardBuyAmazon16. Superman: Up in the Sky
Superman crosses the universe to save one lost child, asked at every step whether it’s worth it. King and Andy Kubert’s case for the cape.
17. Superman’s Pal Jimmy Olsen: Who Killed Jimmy Olsen?
Jimmy Olsen fakes his death, uncovers the Olsen family’s feud with the Luthors and goes viral doing stupid stunts. Gloriously silly.
18. Superman: Last Son
A Kryptonian boy crash-lands in Metropolis and Clark tries to raise him while Zod comes calling. Co-written by the director of the 1978 film.
19. Superman: Brainiac
Brainiac comes to bottle Metropolis and Superman learns what happened to Kandor. Johns and Frank’s best Superman story, with a gut-punch in Smallville.
20. Superman and the Legion of Super-Heroes
Superman travels to the 31st century, where Earth has turned against aliens and his own Legion has been outlawed.
21. Son of Superman
Clark, Lois and their son Jon live quietly on a farm until the boy’s powers start to show.
22. Superman: Son of Kal-El: The Truth
Tom Taylor's Jon Kent as Superman tackles climate change, immigration, and queer identity in a genuinely progressive superhero comic.
23. Superman: Kryptonite
A young Superman learns he can be hurt. Cooke’s script and Sale’s retro Metropolis make a small story feel like a classic.
24. Superman: American Alien
Seven snapshots of Clark becoming Superman, each by a different artist. The warmest origin in years, anchored to a Kansas boy.
25. It’s a Bird…
A writer offered the Superman comic can’t connect to the invulnerable hero while his family faces Huntington’s disease.
#959 on the boardBuyAmazon
Buy links are affiliate links: purchases support The Long Box at no extra cost. Affiliate disclosure
























