Ranked by readers
The 25 best Jeff Lemire comics
Sweet Tooth, Essex County, Black Hammer and Descender.
The top 25 of 37 Jeff Lemire comics on the board. We set the starting order. Reader votes move it. Vote on the full board.
1. Black Hammer: Secret Origins
Lemire's heroes are stranded in a small town with no memory of how they arrived; a meditation on superhero mythology, retirement, and regret.
2. Essex County
Generations of a rural Ontario farming community, an orphaned boy, an old hockey player and a nurse. Lemire’s breakthrough.
3. Sweet Tooth: Out of the Deep Woods
A half-deer boy and a hard man cross a plague-emptied America. Lemire’s scratchy line makes tenderness and dread share a page.
4. Gideon Falls: The Black Barn
Lemire and Sorrentino build a horror machine out of a derelict barn and a fracturing reality. The layouts alone induce vertigo.
5. Descender: Tin Stars
Lemire's gorgeous sci-fi; a young robot boy named Tim-21 may be the key to the universe's fate after giant machines destroyed civilization.
6. Animal Man: The Hunt
Lemire's meta-horror sends Buddy Baker's family fleeing from the Rot; Foreman's angular, disturbing art perfectly captures the grotesque.
7. Phantom Road: Vol. 1
A trucker picks up a strange object from a wreck and finds himself driving a road between worlds.
8. The Bone Orchard Mythos: The Passageway
A geologist sent to a remote island lighthouse investigates a pit that seems to have no bottom.
#451 on the boardBuyAmazon9. Little Monsters: Vol. 1
A gang of vampire children have lived for centuries in an empty city, until one of them finds a human.
10. Snow Angels: Vol. 1
Two sisters live in an endless frozen trench with their father, until a stranger comes up the ice.
#484 on the boardBuyAmazon11. Primordial
The animals sent into space by the Soviets and the Americans in the 1950s didn’t die. They were taken.
12. Mazebook
A grieving building inspector gets a phone call from his dead daughter and follows a maze she drew into another world.
13. Ascender: The Haunted Galaxy
Lemire and Nguyen turn their sci-fi saga into fantasy — magic returns to the galaxy. The watercolour wonder carries over intact.
14. Animal Man: Rotworld: The Red Kingdom
Lemire and Pugh follow Buddy Baker through a world the Rot has consumed. Family drama wrapped in genuine body horror.
15. Gideon Falls: Original Sins
The Black Barn’s reality-warp metastasizes. Lemire and Sorrentino keep reinventing the page itself to render a mind coming apart.
16. Black Hammer: Age of Doom Part 1
Lemire and Ormston deepen their melancholy riff on the Justice League stranded on a farm. The mystery of the town finally cracks.
#622 on the boardBuyAmazon17. Moon Knight: Lunatic
Jeff Lemire sends Marc Spector through fractured identities and asylum walls; psychologically dense and visually daring.
18. Descender: Singularities
Nguyen’s watercolours keep making a robot-boy space opera feel hand-painted and sad. The backstories land hardest here.
19. Sweet Tooth: In Captivity
Gus caged in a militia camp while Jepperd reckons with his betrayal. Lemire turns the screws on the book’s broken father figure.
20. Gideon Falls: The Pentoculus
Reality fully shatters as the Black Barn’s purpose clarifies. Lemire and Sorrentino’s formal pyrotechnics reach their dizzying peak.
21. Descender: The Machine War
The war between humans and robots reaches its end, and TIM-21 learns what the Harvesters really are.
22. Black Hammer: The Event
The mystery of the Event that brought the heroes to their small town begins to unravel; Lemire deepens both the mystery and the emotion.
23. Moon Knight: Welcome to New Egypt
Lemire and Smallwood weaponise the format itself to render Marc Spector’s shattered mind. The most formally daring Moon Knight run.
#669 on the boardBuyAmazon24. Green Arrow: The Kill Machine
Ollie loses everything and learns his island was part of a plan. Lemire and Sorrentino’s stylish rebuild of the character.
25. Black Hammer: Age of Doom Part 2
Lemire and Ormston land their melancholy superhero mystery. A finale that earns every bit of its bittersweetness.
#696 on the boardBuyAmazon
Buy links are affiliate links: purchases support The Long Box at no extra cost. Affiliate disclosure

























